CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT
                         An Annotated Bibliograpy
                         Sources: ERIC & PsyLit
                                    

Compiled by: William G. Huitt, August, 1994

Return to: | Readings in Educational Psychology | Educational Psychology Interactive |


General
Astin, Alexander W. (1992). Values, Assessment, and Academic Freedom: A
Challenge to the Accrediting Process. North Central Association Quarterly, 67(2),
295-306.
Underscores the value and responsibilities of institutional autonomy in higher
education.  Challenges institutions to pay more attention to the development of such
qualities as citizenship, character, honesty, and social responsibilities and to reflect
these values in the curriculum, pedagogical methods, personnel policies, resource
allocation, and outcomes assessment.
Berger, Michael L. (1982, Fall). The Public Schools Can't Do It All. Contemporary
Education; v54 n1 p6-8.
The role assumed by public schools in teaching affective subjects is discussed.  It is
argued that public schools have become scapegoats through their incapability of
teaching such subjects as sex and drug education, moral development, and values
clarification--subjects which should be the responsibility of the family and church.
Buechler, Mark; And Others. (1989). The Debate Over Corporal Punishment. Policy
Memo Series No. 5. Consortium on Educational Policy Studies, Bloomington, IN.
Corporal punishment, the act of disciplining students by inflicting physical pain
(usually paddling the child's backside), has recently come under fire due to the
public's growing concern over child abuse.  Opponents of corporal punishment assert
that there is little hard evidence showing that physical punishment promotes character
development or produces lasting behavioral change.  In fact, opponents claim that
corporal punishment can be counterproductive by increasing rather than curtailing
antisocial behavior.  Corporal punishment supporters believe that coddling students
who deserve to be punished is likely to do lasting harm; supporters suggest that
children who do not learn that misbehavior has unfortunate consequences may never
learn to behave acceptably.  Currently, according to federal court rulings, school
authorities can use reasonable physical punishment unless board policies or state laws
stipulate otherwise.  Across the 32 states that permit corporal punishment in their
public schools, the laws vary considerably.  Most states provide general authority to
administer corporal punishment, but a few discourage this disciplinary technique. 
Whether corporal punishment continues to be used as a disciplinary tool will
ultimately be resolved through the legislative process.
Campbell, Anne. (1985). Components of Rural School Excellence. Department of
Education, Washington, DC. Paper presented at the National Rural Education Forum
(Kansas City, MO, August 12-14.
Although intrusive factors--such as the economy--have limited recent strides toward
improving rural education, there are components of excellence within the realm of
local determination that are appropriate to conditions, circumstances, and aspirations
surrounding the schooling process in rural areas.  The educational reform movement
in most states has resulted in increased requirements that must be considered by rural
educators/boards/citizens.  While these mandates set parameters, local communities
can determine goals and practices for the excellence components of content, standards
and expectations, time, teaching and the teacher, and reinforcement of cultural mores. 
Rural communities can decide to meet or exceed minimum standards, with provision
made to meet the needs of all children.  Communities should take adequate time to
identify issues, propose options, develop curriculum, and meet needs of students
requiring instructional diversity.  Teachers should not only be involved in the content
process but should be accepted as members of the communities that recruit them.  The
additional preparation required of rural teachers should be supported by in-service and
staff development, evaluation, career ladders, and incentive pay.  Cultural mores can
be reinforced by integrating character development into the school environment. 
These components of rural school excellence do not exhaust the list of items that could
be explored.
Education Commission of the States. (1985). Civic Virtues and Character
Development among Youth. A Leadership Symposium Hosted by the Education
Commission of the States (Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, July 24, 1985). No. CD-85-1.
Denver, CO: Author.
A belief that teachers and the school environment cannot be neutral forces in terms of
shaping attitudes and behavior, that a publicly supported school should make no
apology for trying to help young people understand and incorporate into their lives
those civic virtues that almost everyone agrees are important to a democracy, plus a
perceived need for more dialogue and research in this area underlies this symposium
on the topic of values education.  Approximately 200 key policy makers in the United
States who provide leadership in citizenship education and character development at
the K-12 levels of schooling were invited to attend.  Presented in this document are:
the symposium agenda; a list of 23 principles developed by participants for advancing
civic virtues and character development among youth; a list of the participants; a
bibliography of 102 readings recommended by the invitees; and copies of 19 handouts
provided by the symposium presenters which explain the various programs and goals
of their respective institutions.
Crossley, Kathy. (1990). Excellence in Education: Blue Ribbon Schools Program.
Schools Recognized 1982-83 through 1989-90. Office of Educational Research and
Improvement (ED), Washington, DC: Programs for the Improvement of Practice.
Effective public and private schools selected for recognition by the Secondary School
Recognition Program and the Elementary School Recognition Program for 1982-1983
through 1989-1990 are listed in this brochure.  Criteria for selection are concerned
with organization, leadership, curriculum, instruction, student achievement, character
development, school climate, community involvement, initiatives for educational
quality, and philosophy and goals.  Individual schools are listed by state and year of
participation.
Developing Character: Transmitting Knowledge. Sustaining the Momentum for
Reform in American Education. (1984). A Thanksgiving Day Statement by a Group of
27 Americans. Thanksgiving Statement Group, Posen, IL. J.M. Foundation, New
York, N.Y.; Johnson Foundation, Inc., Racine, Wis.
A joint statement by 27 scholars, educators, and policymakers focuses on the question
of character development in American education, as well as the general need to sustain
the momentum of reform brought about by numerous national reports on education. 
Following an executive summary which presents a rationale for the statement, material
is divided into nine sections.  Each section addresses a particular issue: developing
good character in the young, improving academic performance by all students,
maintaining demands on the academically talented, strenghtening teachers and
teaching, upgrading curriculum and textbooks, providing choice for parents and
pupils, revitalizing education policymaking and research, re-evaluating undergraduate
education, and receiving accurate information on schools and pupils.  For each issue,
an explanatory paragraph is followed by discussion and several concrete
recommendations.  Where relevant, charts and graphs provide statistical support for
general statements.  A concluding statement is accompanied by a chart allocating
responsibility for action on the nine issues to parents, teachers, schools, districts,
government agencies, the media, researchers, higher education, private interest
groups, citizens, and the courts.  Statements of partial dissent by some signers
concludes the publication.
Gottfredson, Gary D. (1986). Using the Effective School Battery in School
Improvement and Effective Schools Programs. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University,
Center for Social Organization of Schools. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of
the American Educational Research Association (67th, San Francisco, CA, April
16-20).
The Effective School Battery (ESB) is a diagnostic tool used for assessing school
climate and providing a sound basis for planning and evaluating school improvement
programs.  This paper provides a brief look at the development of the ESB and
describes its basic features.  The ESB serves for diagnosing problems, opening up
communication, evaluating improvement programs, and providing some indicators of a
school's organizational health.  Many school characteristics cited in the effective
schools literature are measured by the ESB, though some characteristics unsuited to
measurement are not.  The ESB permits development of a comprehensive rather than a
unidimensional image of the school.  Among the characteristics tested are school-site
leadership, use of instructional time, establishment of goals and expectations,
recognition of academic achievement, parental involvement, orderliness and security
of the environment, performance monitoring methods, collegiality and collaboration,
staff development, teacher-student relations, student participation, the sense of
community, and district support.  The standard of effectiveness is extended to include
character development as well as academic achievement.  Practical questions about the
ESB are posed and answered.  Appended are samples of graphs displaying ESB
findings, tables of the ESB scales and their meanings, and a three-page list of
references.
Kofodimos, Joan. (1990). Using biographical methods to understand managerial style
and character. Special Issue: Character and leadership. Journal of Applied Behavioral
Science, 26(4), 433-459.
Describes a biographical action research (BAR) approach used to understand
managers' behavior and foster their development.  A theoretical framework of
managerial style and personality was developed and used to determine the underlying
forces within each S's character shaped by that person's life history and environment
and reinforced by organizational values and norms.  The key principles of the BAR
approach are to gather multiple perspectives, use multiple methods, and combine
research and service.  Applications of the framework and principles in studying and
consulting to executives are described, with details of the case study of one S
highlighted.  The dilemmas of BAR involve resulting emotional repercussions,
reporting data accurately without compromising Ss' anonymity, and balancing service
to clients with the scientific pursuit of knowledge.  The benefits include deeper
understanding of the manager's style, behavior, character, and development.
London, Perry. (1987). Character Education and Clinical Intervention: A Paradigm
Shift for U.S. Schools. Phi Delta Kappan; v68 n9 p667-73.
In response to changing social norms and "psychosocial epidemics" disrupting
children's lives, schools must become more important agents of character
development, providing education in civic virtue and personality adjustment.  Schools'
"damage control" function cannot succeed without involving families and reevaluating
existing intervention training and research strategies.  Includes 24 references.
McAvoy, Brenda. (Ed.). (1987). The Principal as Academician: The Renewed Voice.
Atlanta: Georgia State University, Principals Institute.
This collection of essays was written by principals who participated in the 1986-87
Humanities Seminar sponsored by the Principals' Institute of Georgia State University. 
The focus was "The Evolution of Intellectual Leadership." The roles of the principal
as philosopher, historian, ethnician, writer and team member are examined through
the eyes of philosophers, historians, and language scholars.  Twelve participants
contributed to this publication.  The 12 contributions to this publication are: (1) "A
Position Paper Regarding the Educational Profession and the Humanities" (Ron Lane);
(2) "Thoughts on the Principal as Historian" (M. C. Specht); (3) "The Administrator
as Historian" (Jim Ovbey); (4) "The Ethics of Competitiveness: Excellence Versus
Success" (Linda Gruehn); (5) "The New Wave: Ethics Training--Character
Development" (Beverly J. Dryden); (6) "Loneliness Is a Feeling of Without" (J. Carla
Northcutt); (7) "Basic Beliefs" (Michael Cooper); (8) "Education For What?
Krishnamurti's View" (J. B. Mahon); (9) "A Little of Knight's Story" (Burrelle S.
Meeks); (10) "Instructions for the Use and Care of Teachers" (Patricia H.  Cook);
(11) "Inservice" (Paula Calhoun); and (12) "Passing the Torch: The Role of Teachers
in Recruiting the Next Generation of Teachers" (Shirley Davis-Chapman).
McClellan, B. Edward. (1992). Schools and the Shaping of Character: Moral
Education in America, 1607-Present. (Document no.: ED352310).
Debates about how moral education ought to be provided have engaged many of the
best minds in education and stirred public controversies throughout U.S. history.  The
vast array of European peoples who settled the American colonies brought a
commitment to moral education and a variety of approaches to the task.  While French
and Spanish settlers brought Catholicism to the New World, northern European
Protestants did the most to give moral education its character in the original 13
colonies.  The 19th century brought an insistence on rigid self-restraint, moral purity,
and cultural conformity.  Public schools became the preferred educational institutions
for most citizens as state systems expanded rapidly.  A movement to establish
nonsectarian schools grew out of Protestant social thought and modes of organization. 
At the same time, Sunday schools appeared to bring Christian discipline and
discipleship to the working classes.  As the schools of the late 19th and early 20th
centuries expanded their functions, moral education was forced to compete for a place
in an increasingly crowded curriculum.  By the 1940s the role of moral education
began to erode.  Throughout the 1960 and 1970s, schools either adopted neutrality
with regard to moral questions or became indifferent to them.  At the same time,
however, some educators and others sought to restore moral education in the schools. 
In more recent years, there have been efforts: (1) to take nontraditional approaches to
moral education; (2) to restore virtue-centered character education; or (3) to provide
public support to private schools.  Few can doubt that the decision regarding whether
to restore moral education in the schools will be a fateful one.
Murray, Christopher. (1984). Youth Research in the 1980s. Prospects. Quarterly
Review of Education; v14 n2 p211-21.
An overview of youth research from a global perspective is provided.  Five
substantive areas of youth research are identified: (1) youth movements; (2)
transitional processes of youth; (3) social and psychological marginalization; (4)
relationships between generations; and (5) physical and character development.
National School Boards Association. (1987). Building Character in the Public Schools.
Strategies for Success. NSBA Leadership Reports, 1987-2. Alexandria, VA: Author.
The National School Boards Association proposed to the United States Department of
Education a project, "Building Character in the Public Schools," designed to enhance
character development in the schools through involvement of more than 15,000 local
school boards in this country.  The project had two overall goals: to heighten national
awareness of the importance of character development programs in local public
schools to the continued success and stability of American society; and to encourage
the establishment and improvement of character development programs in public
elementary and secondary schools.  The first chapter deals with the triggering
conditions and problems surrounding this problem.  Chapter 2 reflects on several
approaches to the definition of character education.  The remaining chapters describe
the methods that boards desiring to respond to this issue can take to ensure
development of effective character education policies and programs in their school
systems.  Policy development guidelines and implementation procedures relevant to
character building in the public schools are listed.  Appended are: (1) a list of
resources; (2) 16 different sample policies; and (3) sample implementation aids.
Newman, Anabel P. (1985). Twenty Lives Nineteen Years Later: A Longitudinal
Study (1964-1983) of the Impact of Literacy on the Occupations, Schooling, and
Educational Growth of Young Adults Who Were Low-Reading Readiness in First
Grade with Special Attention Given to Model, Motivation, Interest, Perseverance, and
Pressure as Aspects of Background and Mental Environment. Indiana University,
Language Education Department.  The study described in this report had a threefold
purpose: (1) to examine, over time, the development of young adults who, when in
the first grade in a midwestern school system, were in the lower third of their classes;
(2) to examine the effect of literacy on their educational attainment, occupational
level, and achievement; and (3) to examine the part cultural and family experiences
play in student growth and development.  The five chapters of the report explain the
background and need for the study; describe related research that showed that the
intangible variables of model, motivation, interest, perseverance, and pressure played
a large part in the development of the young people; outline the design and
methodology of the study, which involved telephone interviews with the young adults
and their parents; relate the findings and conclusions from the interviews; offer
summaries; and make recommendations for learners with characteristics similar to
those in the study--their interests, self-concepts, coping skills, values, character
development, socialization, and thinking skills.  Half of the volume consists of
appendices.  These include a research chronology, sample interview questionnaires,
and student and parent interview tables.
Passow, A. Harry. (1985). Developing Character: Transmitting Knowledge--The
Thanksgiving Statement--One Assessment of a Statement on Education Policy. Paper
presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association
(69th, Chicago, IL, March 31-April 4).
Developing Character: Transmitting Knowledge, a statement signed by 27 educators
intended to sustain the momentum for reform in American education, is discussed and
critiqued.  The author declined to sign the Statement and was asked to critically
evaluate it.  The Statement presents nine major issues, follows with a discussion of
each, and concludes with a set of recommendations concerning each issue.  Although
the report criticizes the national reform reports for not dealing adequately with the
topic of youth character, the Statement avoids such strategies as values education or
sex education, and seems not to come to grips with the elements of character
development which require cognitive and affective development and the creation of a
climate of community in the school.  The recommendations are viewed by this critic
as restatements of the recommendations from some of the national reform reports such
as "A Nation at Risk." He believes the recommendations are conservative and
traditional and stray from the focus on character development of youth.  By attempting
to deal with the whole of education and schooling rather than those issues and
recommendations concerning character development, the result is a Statement which is
too traditional, too conservative, and too general.
Seuffert, Virginia. (1990). Home Remedy: A Mom's Prescription for Ailing Schools.
Policy Review; n52 p70-75.
Discusses the history and advantages of home schooling.  Reviews available curricula. 
Emphasizes immediate feedback, character development shaped by family values and
religious beliefs, and low per-pupil costs.
Teplitsky, Alan. (1987). Life, Literature, and Character: Some Cornerstone
Principles. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the National Council of Teachers
of English Spring Conference (6th, Louisville, KY, March 26-28).
There is a widely felt need to do something in education about the moral wasteland of
contemporary American society.  It is appropriate for English teachers to posit some
usable dimensions of moral education.  Seven cornerstone principles appear to be
universally involved both in the lives of literary characters and in the kind of
heart-deep character development which educators try to nurture in students through
the English curriculum.  The seven principles are: design, authority, conscience, love,
power, destiny, and wisdom.  The principles suggest a possible thematic scope and
sequence for a complete literature curriculum, both within and between grade levels. 
Within each grade level the central theme could be examined in the light of each of
the other principles.  Presented in this way, the cornerstone principles would generate
a kind of spiral curriculum of morally educative units, each year adding to the
students' understanding of important social and ethical values.  Year after year, they
can be engaged in a vital and personal experiencing of literature, be asked questions
that require them to come to grips with some universal principles of character, and be
motivated toward an active involvement in solving personal and community problems. 
A series of exercises revolving around Shakespeare's "Hamlet" illustrate how the
cornerstone principles can be applied.  Educators must recognize that character
development is a lifelong process, and that there are more key factors outside the
classroom than in it.  (One figure is included; two extensive appendixes containing a
character development ladder and a detailed examination of the cornerstone principles,
and 82 endnotes are attached.)
Walsh, Kevin. (1990). The Three Dimensions of Education. Paper presented at the
Annual Meeting of the Pennsylvania School Boards Association (Lewisburg, PA, July
19-21).
Three dimensions of education--development of knowledge, training of mental
abilities, and development of character--and their implications for social and individual
good are discussed in this paper.  Education is described as the process that prepares
young people for their social inheritance through the transmission of societal values. 
A recommendation is that knowledge development should be based on cultural
knowledge and should stress student effort over whatever interests the child already
happens to have.  Mental discipline, or learning how to complete responsibility, is the
central premise of the training of mental ability.  The first two dimensions contribute
to character development, which transmits cultural and moral values through
discipline.  Education is based on the premise that knowledge does not give rise to a
culture's character, but rather the character of a culture gives rise to its knowledge
and direction.  A conclusion is that failure to develop character and morality through
education fails the fundamental premise of education--the preparation of the young to
inherit and strengthen their society.
Wilson, James Q. (1983). Crime and American Culture. Ethics and Public Policy
Essay #43.  Ethics and Public Policy Center, Washington, DC. Document no:
ED289750.
The great waves of foreign immigration, the onset of rapid industrialization, the
emergence of an urban working class--all features of the post Civil War United States
that might have contributed to rising crime rates--did not.  Ted Robert Gurr suggests
that a growth of the "civilizing process" occurred in which people turned away from
violence and internalized or displaced aggressive impulses.  The process began among
upper socio-economic groups and was given institutional expression in various reform
movements.  Beginning in the 1920s, the educated classes in America repudiated
moral improvement as it had been defined during the preceding century.  Child
rearing views began to change in the 1920s.  Character development was replaced
with personality development.  By the 1960s, the baby boom generation had come of
age.  The psychology of radical individualism and the philosophy of individual rights
triumphed.  The factors that most directly influence crime (family structure, moral
development, the level of personal freedom) are the very things that U.S.  citizens do
not easily change or, for persuasive reasons, do not wish to change.  Law becomes
more important as informal social control becomes less important.  Thousands of
neighborhood organizations and civic enterprises have emerged from a desire to
reduce crime by direct popular action.  This recourse to informal communal action has
grown out of a reaffirmed allegiance to a communal theory of social control.
Wynne, Edward. (1986). Character Development: Renewing an Old Commitment.
Principal; v65 n3 p28-31.
Growing public concern with student discipline, increases in student suicide rates,
homicides, and high pregnancy rates of teenage girls are causing educators to give
renewed attention to the concept of "character development" in public education.
Wynne, Edward, & Walberg, Herbert. (1986, January). Pupil Characteristics and
Academics--Concurrent Priorities. NASSP Bulletin; v70 n486 p59-66.
The recommendations set forth in "Developing Character: Transmitting Knowledge," a
recent statement signed by prominent scholars and educators, are reviewed here for
principals.  The statement focuses on the importance of education for character
development.
Wynne, Edward, & Walberg, Herbert. (1985-1986). The Complementary Goals of
Character Development and Academic Excellence. Educational Leadership; v43 n4
p15-18.
Academically successful schools need to master student discipline and accept that
character development is as important as academic development.  Provides
recommendations on how schools can do both.
Youngs, Bettie B. (1993). Self-Esteem in the School: More than a "Feel-Good"
Movement. NASSP Bulletin, 76(549), 59-66.
The six vital ingredients of student self-esteem are physical safety, emotional security,
identity, affiliation, competence, and mission.  Educational reform efforts will not
succeed until educators reinforce character-building practices promoting self-respect as
a basis for learning and achieving.  Principals must provide leadership in staff
development, parent participation, recognition of new work demands, and
development of a health school environment.
Philosophical Issues
Beller, Edward. (1986, August). Education for Character: An Alternative to Values
Clarification and Cognitive Moral Development Curricula. Journal of Educational
Thought; v20 n2 p67-76.
Discusses the weaknesses inherent in Sidney Simon's values clarification method and
Lawrence Kohlberg's cognitive moral development method, suggesting that single
class, isolated instruction overlooks the affective, unconscious elements of character
formation.  Recommends an alternative holistic approach based on John Locke's
concept of all education as education for character development.
Bermeo, Franklin H. (1979). Ellen G. White's theory of character development with
inferences suggested by selected contemporary psychologists. Dissertation Abstracts
International, Vol 40(3-A), 1379.
Miller, Peter J.; Kim, Ki Su. (1988). Human Nature and the Development of
Character: The Clash of Descriptive and Normative Elements in John Stuart Mill's
Educational Theory. Journal of Educational Thought; v22 n2 p133-44.
Discusses John Stuart Mill's belief in the development of character as a solution to
social problems and a worthy educational ideal.  Concludes that Mill's belief in
education's power to perfect human nature through character development could not
be realized within the framework of his anthropological views of human kind.
Shermis, S. Samuel; Barth, James L. (1982). Teaching for Passive Citizenship: A
Critique of Philosophical Assumptions. Theory and Research in Social Education; v10
n4 p17-37.
While educators have always talked about active citizenship and critical thought,
classroom practices have emphasized passive acquisition and character development. 
Teachers' philosophical assumptions that enable them to train future citizens to
become passive spectators are discussed.
Taylor, Michael R. (1982). Character and autonomy: The paradox of moral education.
Dissertation Abstracts International, Vol 43(3-A), 827.
Statewide Efforts
Arizona State Department of Education. (1990). Character Development in the 90s: A
Reaffirmation of Values. Teaching Values in Arizona Schools. The Report of the Task
Force on Values in Education for the State of Arizona. Phoenix: Author.
Pursuant to a request from the Arizona State Board of Education, an interagency task
force was formed in fall 1989 to examine the issue of values instruction in Arizona
schools.  This document begins with a summary of the resulting report, along with a
list of suggested common core values, recommendations for development and
implementation of a values instruction program, and an historical perspective on
values instruction.  Appended is the full text of the task force report, "Character
Development in the 90s: A Reaffirmation of Values." This report states and develops
10 consensual premises underlying values instruction: (1) that values need to be
taught; (2) that society supports an increased role for the public school in values
instruction; (3) that values instruction needs to be defined; (4) that a common core of
values exists within our society; (5) that values play a role in education and that
teachers and administrators play a part in transmitting values; (6) that values are
taught implicitly and explicitly throughout the curriculum, by instruction, practices,
and personal example; (7) that educators should be aware of differing values and
ethics of the community; (8) that knowledge from research in values education and
child development should be considered in developing a program; (9) that goals of
values instruction should be established in terms of student behavior and character
development; and (10) that a recognized philosophy of values instruction and
commitment to its implementation should be adopted and implemented.  Also
appended are state board members' comments on the values education report and a list
of the values education task force members.  A bibliography is included.
Beswick, Richard. (1992). Character Education. OSSC Bulletin, 35(9).
Although there has been reluctance to support direct methods of teaching moral values
and character traits, due in part to lack of consensus about whose values should be
taught, a national call to rethink that trend has begun to be heard.  An up-to-date
account is provided of the recommendations of the Oregon State Board of Education to
mandate character education throughout Oregon, by December 1992, along with
suggestions on policy and implementation.  This publication explores the need for
character education and shows how a direct approach can work in an interdependent
and multicultural world.  Chapter 1 attempts to define character education and
discusses the need for instilling character traits.  Several modern theories of moral
development and their limitations are also explored in the chapter.  Chapter 2
describes several ongoing character education programs and features Oregon's North
Clackamas School District.  Character education curriculum is the subject of chapter
3.  Finally, chapter 4 deals with the legal and public policy aspect carrying out
character education in Oregon.  The appendix lists seven sources of information on
programs and curriculum.
Ohio State Department of Education. (1990). Character Education in Ohio: Sample
Strategies. Columbus: Author. (Document no.: ED350196).
The Ohio State Department of Education has identified 10 basic values for which
students are to strive.  These individual character traits are compassion, courtesy,
tolerance,honesty, self-discipline, diligence, responsibility, self- respect, courage, and
integrity.  This guide provides sample strategies for educators to help them to develop
these traits in their students.  The guide is comprised of five sections.  Section 1
contains a sample character trait inventory.  The 10 basic values are listed with
statements related to each trait.  The purpose of the instrument is to determine the
extent to which these values are practiced by individuals in the school.  A sample
needs assessment instrument is provided in section 2 of the guide.  It is to be used in
conjunction with the character trait inventory to target aspects of the general school
and classroom environments where action may be needed to ensure that individual
character traits are being addressed.  Goals based on the environmental aspects listed
on the needs assessment tool are established in section 3.  Each goal is followed by
sample activities or lesson plans that address each of the character traits at various
grade levels.  Section 4 provides a model for organizing an advisory committee. 
School districts are encouraged to appoint a broad-based advisory committee to review
the State Board's report, determine the community's values, and develop strategies for
incorporating these values in the schools.  The fifth and final section of the guide is a
listing of books, articles, resource materials, and newsletters that may prove beneficial
in the incorporation of character education in the school environment.
Early and Middle Childhood
Freeman, Evelyn B. (1984). The development of empathy in young children: In search
of a definition. Child Study Journal, Vol 13(4), 235-245.
Investigated (a) the relationship between cognitive and affective dimensions of
empathy and (b) the effects of sex of S and sex and race of stimulus character on
empathy development.  54 White preschoolers (aged 43-67 mo) responded to story
vignettes both in terms of how they themselves felt and how the stimulus child felt. 
Results indicate that a significant positive correlation existed between cognitive and
affective empathy with Ss expressing significantly more cognitive empathy than
affective empathy.  For male Ss, the degree of racial similarity had a significant effect
on the expression of cognitive empathy.  Results are discussed in terms of current
theories regarding empathy development.
Hess, Charlotte M.; Gilgannon, Nancy. (1986). Gaming: A Curriculum Technique for
Elementary Counselors. Paper presented at the Annual Convention of the American
Association for Counseling and Development (Los Angeles, CA, April 20-23).
Recently, emphasis has been placed on curriculum implementation of character
development.  The elementary school counselor can function as a curriculum
consultant by providing a delivery system for affective goals and objectives in the
curriculum.  Elementary counselors can help administrators and teachers to define
learning problems and establish program goals, collect data to assist in determining
teaching methodology and strategies, develop a plan and design curriculum, implement
the plan, and evaluate the effectiveness of instruction.  A useful instructional strategy
which has suffered a decline in popularity is gaming.  Gaming encourages students to
explore, discover, and create.  Counselors and teachers can observe students' gaming
and thus gather information for instructional planning.  One form of gaming, role
playing, is an effective means for developing decision-making and problem solving
skills.  Effective use of gaming involves the development of instructional objectives
and teacher training.  Teachers need to know how to establish affective objectives and
use affective education.  Character development must come through coordinated
learning activities and school counselors have the expertise to act as consultants in this
process.  
Lickona, Thomas. (1989). Character Development in Elementary-Grade Children.
Religion & Public Education; v16 n3 p409-17.
Identifies goals of character development for elementary school children.  Offers four
processes that promote positive social growth and moral maturity: (1) building
self-esteem and a sense of community; (2) learning to cooperate and help others; (3)
reflecting on moral choices; and (4) participating in decision making.  Suggests how
teachers have implemented these processes.
Lickona, Thomas. (1988). Educating the Moral Child. Principal; v68 n2 p6-10.
Spurred by an impending morality crisis, moral education is making a comeback. 
Gallup polls indicate that over 80 percent of parents want public schools to teach
moral values.  This article shows how to promote respect and responsibility as the
fourth and fifth "R's." Insets list values and character development objectives.
Lickona, Thomas. (1988). Four Strategies for Fostering Character Development and
Academics in Children. Phi Delta Kappan; v69 n6 p419-23.
Discusses three goals of character development for elementary school children:
promoting (1) cooperative relationships and mutual respect; (2) moral agency; and (3)
a moral community based on fairness, caring, and participation.  Explores teaching
strategies for building self-esteem and fostering cooperation, moral reflection, and
participative decision making.  Incudes five references.
McKee, Patricia; And Others. (1986). A Salute to Success: The Elementary School
Recognition Program. Principal; v66 n1 p14-19.
In October 1984, Education Secretary William Bennett proclaimed 1985-86 the "Year
of the Elementary School" and announced the Elementary School Recognition
Program.  The program's goal was to focus national attention on schools providing
high-quality instructional and character development programs.  This article lists the
270 winning schools by state.
Schaps, Eric; And Others. (1985-1986). A Program that Combines Character
Development and Academic Achievement. Educational Leadership; v43 n4 p32-35.
Describes the Child Development Project in California, which holds that academic and
character education are equally important goals for schools.  The project has been
established to produce long-lasting effects on children's "prosocial" development.
Wynne, Edward (1988). Balancing Character Development and Academics in the
Elementary School. Phi Delta Kappan; v69 n6 p424-26.
Describes the For Character Program that identifies and honors public and private
schools in which students demonstrate high levels of positive conduct and academic
effort.  Outlines several school and classroom management principles that stress both
character development and academic quality and resemble effective school
characteristics.
Yeatts, Karol L. (1990). Establishing an Affective School Environment To Enhance
Character Development in Pre K-3rd Grade Students Using Storytelling Techniques.
Ed.D. Practicum, Nova University. Document no: ED321901.
During an 8-month period, a primary school teacher designed and implemented a
practicum study intended to socialize children in prekindergarten through 3rd-grade
classes to be cooperative, responsible, and achieving individuals.  Primary goals of the
practicum were to develop a nurturing affective environment, enhance character
development, decrease behavioral problems, and enhance home and school relations. 
A literature review provided: (1) evidence of the importance of an affective
environment for the enhancement of character development; and (2) suggestions for
establishment of such an environment.  The effort to establish a positive, nurturing
affective environment involved getting support from school administration and the
Parent Teacher Association, writing a proposal for an education grant to purchase
education materials, arranging teacher in-service and peer-teacher support activities,
and providing teachers with suggestions, activities, and support.  Practicum evaluation
data indicated effectiveness in improving character development and decreasing
behavior problems.  An emphasis on story writing and story telling resulted in over
600 works by students.  Questionnaires and other measures, instructional materials,
and additional materials used in the practicum are appended.
Middle Grades
Fenwick, James J. (1987). Caught in the Middle. Educational Reform for Young
Adolescents in California Public School. Report of the Superintendent's Middle Grade
Task Force. Sacramento: Bureau of Adult Education. California State Department of
Education.
Twenty-two principles of middle grade education are addressed in this report, which is
intended for those who have the authority to give meaning and substance to the reform
of middle grade education in California's public schools.  Each principle is developed
through a discussion that concludes with specific recommendations that have
implications for legislative initiatives, educational policies, administrative guidelines,
and professional practices.  Part One, "Curriculum and Instruction: Achieving
Academic Excellence," provides recommendations in the areas of core curriculum,
knowledge, thinking and communication, character development, learning to learn,
and instructional practice.  Part Two, entitled "Student Potential: Realizing the
'Highest and Best' Intellectual, Social, Emotional, and Physical Development," covers
academic counseling, equal access, student diversity and underrepresented minorities,
at-risk students, and physical and emotional development.  Part Three, "Organization
and Structure: Creating New Learning Environments," addresses school culture,
extracurricular and intramural activities, student accountability, transition, structure,
scheduling, and assessment.  Part Four, "Teaching and Administration: Preparing for
Exemplary Performance," focuses on professional preparation and staff development. 
Part Five, entitled "Leadership and Partnership: Defining the Catalysts for Middle
Grade Educational Reform," focuses on sharing accountability for educational reform
among parents, communities, and school boards, and concludes with a proposal for a
partnership to create 100 state-of-the-art middle schools.  Appended are (1) an outline
of middle-grade student characteristics; (2) a tabular "accountability matrix" for the
recommendations as a whole; and (3) a selected bibliography of books and articles on
middle grade education.  
Honig, Bill. (1988). Middle Grade Reform. Social Education; v52 n2 p119-20.
Discusses California's Middle Grade Task Force and its report, "Caught in the
Middle: Educational Reform for Young Adolescents in California Public Schools."
Describes the 1987 revision of the California history-social science framework which
emphasizes character development through studying the moral and ethical struggles of
literary and historical figures.
Thompson, Denise R. (1989). METRO Achievement Program: Summer 1988.
External Evaluation Report. Chicago: METRO Achievement Program. Document no:
ED317651.
This document comprises an evaluation of the 1988 METRO Achievement Program, a
summer educational program to help develop the academic potential of primarily Black
and Hispanic girls entering the seventh and eighth grades in Chicago.  The 5-week
program included the following components: (1) mathematics, science, and
communication skills classes; (2) a character development class; (3) a fine arts class;
(4) team sports; (5) personal counseling; and (6) field trips.  Evaluation information
was gathered from surveys of participants, parents, and advisors, and from
comparison surveys of girls in five of the schools from which METRO recruits
participants.  The following findings are reported: (1) only seventh-grade blacks and
eighth-grade Hispanics showed significant increases in self-esteem and seventh-grade
Hispanics showed a decrease in self-esteem; (2) the overall patterns of self-esteem
were similar to those of the five comparison schools but the individual measures of
participants were better than those at the comparison schools; (3) parents and advisors
perceived increases in participants' self-confidence and self-assurance, and reported
that a majority of the participants became less shy and more outgoing; (4) participants
reported liking the program and one-sixth reported having learned something new; (5)
almost all participants would recommend the program to others; (6) 20 percent of the
participants reported an increase in self-confidence; and (7) eighth-grade participants
were much more positive about the academic classes than seventh-graders. 
Recommendations for improvement are suggested.  Thirty-seven tables of statistical
data, copies of the survey questionnaires, and a list of 82 references are appended.
High School
Bauer, Rodney W. (1992, January). Correlates of student character development in a
small high school. Dissertation Abstracts International, Vol 52(7-A), 2491.
Kessler, Glenn R., & Ibrahim, Farah A. (1986, Spring). Character development in
adolescents. Adolescence, Vol 21(81), 1-9.
Explored the effect of a program consisting of communication and counseling skills,
assertiveness training, and moral dilemmas on the character development (i.e., moral
reasoning, ego development, and assertiveness) of 54 high school seniors.  It was
hypothesized that exposure to the experimental treatment would enhance Ss' character
development.  Ss, who were enrolled in 3 psychology classes, were assigned randomly
to 2 treatment groups and 1 control group.  Assessment instruments were the Defining
Issues Test, to measure moral reasoning; the Washington University Sentence
Completion Test, to measure ego development; and an assertiveness schedule.  A
repeated measures analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to determine significant
differences between control and treatment posttest means with respect to the dependent
variables--moral reasoning, ego development, and assertiveness.  Results demonstrate
that the character development of Ss in the experimental treatment group was affected
significantly over time by the program, with measurable improvements noted in all 3
character development indices.
Maher, Robert. (1988). Leadership: Self, School, Community. Reston, VA: National
Association of Secondary School Principals, Division of Student Activities.
This book describes Character Development and Leadership Training in the School
and Community, a high school course instituted at Lakeland High School in Shrub
Oak, New York in 1983.  It was written to help other educators interested in
implementing similar student leadership programs.  The developer of the program
explains some of his reasons for starting the course, techniques which have proven
successful in moving it forward, valuable community resources, and some problems
and roadblocks encountered and avoided in the program implementation.  Vandalism
and loitering in the school are cited as reasons for beginning the program at Lakeland. 
It is noted that a successful program in character development and leadership training
must serve three needs: the improvement of self, of school, and of community.  The
main objective of the program is to encourage students to better themselves by
knowing themselves and the kinds of leadership roles they are best suited to perform;
in the course of this development, to better the school as an educational and social
community so that the student body will encounter a healthy and supportive
atmosphere for their growth as scholars and persons; and, finally, to become involved
in established community organizations.  Chapters in the book describe student
selection for the program, the leadership application, sample exercises and
descriptions, committees in action, individual projects, the School Watch Program,
special projects, the summer break, teachers, grading, and readings and films.
Maryland State Department of Education. (1989). Bridge to the Future. Addressing
The Needs of Students At Risk during the High School Years. Technical Team
Report. Submitted to the Commission for Students At Risk of School Failure.
Baltimore: Author.
This report analyzes practices and conditions that seek to prevent at-risk behaviors
among adolescents.  Discussion begins with a description of the developmental tasks
that adolescents need to complete before they can assume productive adult roles in
society.  While two conflicting views of adolescence are noted, the capacity of young
people to change is supported.  The report examines characteristics of home, school,
and community environments that support the healthy physical, emotional, social,
cognitive, and character development of adolescents.  The report then outlines a
process for identifiying at-risk adolescents and highlights some intervention designs for
youths already displaying at-risk behaviors.  Interventions include academic support,
pupil services and social services supports, career preparation and experiential
learning, schools of choice, and school reorganization.  Concluding discussion
concerns two challenges to those attempting to make changes that will benefit high
school students.  For each challenge, barriers that will need to be dealt with are listed. 
Forty-three profiles of intervention programs that serve as examples across the nation
are appended.  A list of 65 references is provided.
University/College Age
Bliming, Gregory S. (1990, Summer). Developing Character in College Students.
NASPA Journal; v27 n4 p266-74.
Examines four problems associated with developing character in college students: two
concerned with moral cognition, or knowing what is right, and two concerned with
moral action.  It then reviews educational programs concerned with moral action, and
provides suggestions for designing character development strategies.
Dalton, Jon. (Ed.). (1985). Promoting Values Development in College Students.
Monograph Series, Volume 4. Columbus, OH: National Association of Student
Personnel Administrators, Inc. Document no.: ED272803.
This monograph was written to examine the significance of recent moral development
theory and research for college student development and to demonstrate ways in which
these findings can be incorporated into student affairs programs and services. 
Although the monograph includes some review and discussion of research and theory
in values development, it is intended primarily for student personnel practitioners. 
The following chapters are included: (1) "The Legacy of Values Education in College
Student Personnel Work" (Arthur Sandeen); (2) "Values Education: A New Priority
for College Student Development" (Jon C.  Dalton); (3) "Influences of Character
Development During the College Years: The Retrospective View of Recent
Undergraduates" (John M.  Whiteley, et al); (4) "Critical Factors in the Value
Development Process" (Jon C.  Dalton); (5) "Planning a Comprehensive Values
Education Program" (Jon C.  Dalton, et al); and (6) "Evaluating Moral Development"
(James R.  Rest).  Also included are a conclusion by Martha McGinty Stodt and an
annotated bibliography (66 entries) by James Thorius.  The appendix provides short
summaries of the method and goals of 10 sample values education programs.
Dunn, Dana S. (1992, March). Freud, Problem Solving, Ethnicity, and Race:
Integrating Psychology into the Interdisciplinary Core Curriculum. (Document no.:
ED350065).
The new core curriculum at Moravian College, in Pennsylvania, utilizes an
interdisciplinary approach, integrating topics of psychology into three of the seven
core courses: "Microcosm/Macrocosm"; "Quantitative Problem Solving"; and 
Durand, Henry F., & Reister, Barry W. (1987). Management Theory Meets Student
Development Theory: Implications for Student Affairs Programming. NASPA Journal,
25(2), 82-90.
One goal of student affairs programming is the promotion of character development. 
Based on the assumption that empathy training will have a significant impact on
character development, a study was designed which incorporated the listening skills
(empathy) training of the Sierra Project (Whitely, 1982) with the Hersey/Blanchard
model for situational leadership.  College students' (N=39) scores on Kagan's
Affective Sensitivity Scale fell within four groups of empathy readiness: R1 (low
motivation/low ability), R2 (high motivation/low ability), R3 (high ability/low
motivation), and R4 (high ability, high motivation).  Subjects were then divided into
four listening skills training workshop conditions: S1 (high task/low relationship), S2
(high task/high relationship), S3 (low task/high relationship), and S4 (low task/low
relationship).  In an effort to monitor the effects of the training on self-esteem, a
semantic differential was administered before the workshop began, at the midpoint,
and immediately after the workshop.  The Affective Sensitivity Scale was
readministered after completion of the workshop to measure changes in ability to
empathize.  The results indicated that high skilled students (R3-R4) who participated
in a low structured (S3-S4) treatment did significantly better than high skilled students
who participated in the high structured (S1-S2) intervention.  Low skilled (R1-R2)
students in a high structured (S1-S2) intervention did significantly better than low
skilled students in a low structured (S3-S4) intervention.  Changes in self-esteem
throughout the study indicated the importance of monitoring self-esteem, although at
this time results are only speculative.  
Goodchild, Lester F. (1986). Changes in the Professoriate, the Curriculum, and the
Aim of Higher Education from the Middle Ages to the Modern Era. ASHE Annual
Meeting Paper.
Views from the Middle Ages to the Modern Era are traced concerning the role of
faculty in collegiate education, the curriculum, and desired learning outcomes. 
Previous educational thought concerning faculty, curricula, and mission provides a
historical paradigm in which the ideological orientation of the 1985 Association of
American Colleges' (AAC) report, "Integrity in the College Curriculum" can be
interpreted.  The AAC recommendation to restore the teaching orientation of the
professoriate "as its first obligation" represents a movement away from the thought of
Aquinas, Vergerius, and Ticknow which has characterized American higher education
since the turn of the century.  A revised faculty role emphasizing a greater teaching
and formative orientation toward students' intellectual and character development
represents a shift to the thought of Hugh of St.  Victor, Aquaviva, Erasmus, Day, and
Newman.  The report further endorsed this group's thought when it revitalized the
general education and prescribed manner of the liberal arts curriculum.  The report
also emphasizes wisdom rather than knowledge as desired outcomes.  These
orientations renunciate the current state of the American undergraduate experience
formed during the twentieth century.  However, the report does not fully address the
purpose of the baccalaureate degree.
Hirschhorn, Michael (1987, March 11). Student Entrepreneurs Test World of Business
Deals and "Power Schmoozing." Chronicle of Higher Education; v33 n26 p1,36.
The Association of Collegiate Entrepreneurs is an organization supporting and
promoting student entrepreneurship through positive attitudes, character development,
and enthusiasm.  Student-run businesses are varied, creative, and often highly
successful.
Klingman, Barbara A. (1992, May). The call of the wild: Investigating the
relationship between adventure education, character development, and the college
curriculum. Dissertation Abstracts International, Vol 52(11-A) 3836.
Moral and Ethical Development on the College Campus. A Symposium. (1985).
Bowling Green State Univ., Ohio. Document no.: ED267709.
Issues concerning student moral and ethical development during college are considered
in three papers from a symposium sponsored by Bowling Green State University as
part of the Academic Outcomes Project.  Four major questions are addressed: the
college's role in promoting students' moral and ethical development; what constitutes
moral and ethical development in young adults and adults in general; the degree to
which this type of development occurs among college students; and what types of
collegiate experiences promote or inhibit students' moral and ethical development. 
After an introduction by Patricia M. King, a paper by John M. Whiteley is presented:
"The Development of Values and Ethics During the College Years." Attention is
directed to the Sierra Project, which is a longitudinal study of the effects of a new
approach to character education, and the character development of students during
college.  Three ways to respond to forces that push education to specialization are
proposed by Thomas Klein in "Moral Development: A Faculty Member's
Perspective." Ideas for faculty development, curriculum monitoring and change, and
faculty renewal are included.  Finally, in "Opportunities to Promote Moral
Development: A Dean's Perspective," Donald Schweingruber discusses seven steps to
promote student moral development.
Whiteley, John M. (1990). The Renewal of Opportunity for Enhancing Character
Development during the College Years. Journal of the Freshman Year Experience; v2
n2 p75-87.
Advances in theory and practice make it possible to measure moral reasoning
empirically and offer college-level educational programs enhancing moral
understanding.  Bases for these advances are reviewed, a longitudinal study and
curriculum development effort is described, and the next research frontier, the
relationship of moral reasoning to moral action, is discussed.
Whiteley, John M.; Yokota, Norma. (1988). The Freshman Year Experience.
Character Development in the Freshman Year and over Four Years of Undergraduate
Study. South Carolina Univ., Columbia. Center for the Study of the Freshman Year
Experience. Document no.: ED318323.
The study reviews the impact of the freshman year and 4 years of undergraduate study
on the formation of character and its progression from late adolescence to young
adulthood.  Much of the empirical data used is drawn from the Sierra Project, a study
originating in the 1970s that addressed traditional obstacles in higher education in
meeting its responsibility for character development through curriculum intervention
and longitudinal research.  The study's methodology and results are reported.  Specific
aspects of character development studied include changes in moral maturity, ego
development, and principled thinking during the course of undergraduate study.  The
ways in which the context for promoting personal development can be changed are
examined, and the elements of the Sierra Project curriculum considered central in this
effort are outlined.  Includes 35 references.
Special Education
Gibberman, Charlotte. (1986). Plays for the Special Education Classroom: 10 Short
Plays Designed to Promote Character Development.
This booklet contains 10 short plays written especially for performance by special
education students who ranged in age from five to ten and in academic level from
kindergarten to fourth grade.  The plays focus on promoting character development
and topics include death, prejudice, manners, senior citizens, responsibility for others,
and positive thinking.  In each play, there is a flexible number of parts, and roles may
be played by boys or girls.  The roles are usually of equal length and importance. 
The plays usually take 10 to 15 minutes to perform, and a minimum amount of time is
needed for practice.  Dialogue does not have to be memorized.  Props and costumes
are not required.  The situations presented in the plays parallel real life situations and
provide a nonthreatening forum for class discussions; discussion questions following
each play give students the opportunity to offer their own insights and personal
examples of the problems presented and to find their own solutions.  
Sports and Physical Education
Hodge, Kenneth P. (1988, December). A conceptual analysis of character
development in sport. Dissertation Abstracts International, Vol 49(6-A), 1402.
Miller, Ronald F., & Jarman, Boyd O. (1988). Moral and Ethical Character
Development--Views from Past Leaders. Journal of Physical Education, Recreation
and Dance; v59 n6 p72-78.
Character education is a historical and fundamental objective of a sound physical
education program.  Excerpts from speeches by eminent American physical educators
from 1885 to the present focus on the moral and ethical development of young people
and instilling in them a sense of their potential for spiritual growth.
Romance, Thomas. (1988). Promoting Character Development in Physical Education.
Strategies; v1 n5 p16-17.
The development of character through physical education programs requires the use of
specific methodologies.  This article discusses ways in which physical education
teachers may promote and encourage students' moral development and makes specific
suggestions on how to do so.
Multicultural Issues
Bailey, Becky, & Lee, Gi-Hyoun. (1992). Early Childhood Education in Korea. Paper
presented at the Conference of the Florida Association for Children Under Six
(Orlando, FL, September). (Document no.: ED354069)
The Korean kindergarten curriculum involves a mixture of Japanese, American, and
Korean methods.  The Japanese influence is reflected in the use of large group
instruction and an expectation of uniformity from the children, influences from the
United States include a consideration for children's individual interests, and the
Korean influence is seen in a focus on self-esteem, Korean culture, and a strong
Korean identity.  Korea has two kinds of kindergarten, public and private, both of
which are regulated by the Ministry of Education.  The curriculum focuses on
physical, emotional, cognitive, social, and language development.  Day care is
available for prekindergarten children through day care centers, Semaull Head Start (a
program for low-income children), and infant schools.  Teacher training for early
childhood education relies heavily on vocational training colleges.  Three major
cultural factors which contribute to the character of Korean children are Confucian
ideology, Korea's history as an agricultural country, and the value Korean culture
places on the group.  Korean children express their love and respect for teachers
differently than do American children, and are taught to be quiet and obedient.  It is
important for Americans who teach Korean children to be sensitive to these cultural
differences.
Glenn, Charles L. (1986). New Challenges: A Civil Rights Agenda for the Public
Schools. Phi Delta Kappan; v67 n9 p653-56.
While many poor people of color have not really benefited from antipoverty and
antidiscrimination programs, substantial gains in educational access have been
achieved.  Educators need to redefine objectives to improve minority children's
education, focusing on language skills and character development appropriate to a
diverse, multicultural society.  
Long, Delbert H. (1984). Soviet Education and the Development of Communist
Ethics. Phi Delta Kappan; v65 n7 p469-72.
Surveys characteristics of the Soviet philosophy of education, which emphasizes
character development consonant with Communist Party goals.  Describes the attempts
to train "the new Soviet man."
Lyke, James P. (1987). Sharing the Gifts of the Black Community. Momentum; v18
n1 p8-10.
Offers a summary of the first pastoral letter of the black bishops of the United States,
"What We Have Seen and Heard." Sees the Catholic schools representing an
opportunity for quality education and character development to many in the black
community.
Ohnishi, Fumiyuki. (1988). Current Trends in Psychological Research on Morality in
Japan. Moral Education Forum; v13 n2 p16-19.
Briefly discusses the formation of the Japanese Association of Morality Psychology
and lists the papers presented at its annual meetings since 1985.  Presents a survey of
publications on moral development and education in Japan, organized by theorists such
as Kohlberg and Piaget and themes such as moral development theory.
Pine, Gerald J.; Hilliard, Asa G., III. (1990). Rx for Racism: Imperatives for
America's Schools. Phi Delta Kappan; v71 n8 p593-600.
Racism, prejudice, and discrimination are sabotaging our nation's efforts to provide a
high quality education for all children.  The consequences of institutional racism and
monocultural education are pervasive and profound.  Schools must increase the pool of
minority teachers, develop a multicultural curriculum, improve pedagogical practice,
and teach character development.  Includes 41 references.
Pollak, Susan. (1982). Traditional Indian Education. Cambridge, MA: Harvard
University,  Graduate School of Education. Bernard Van Leer Foundation, The Hague
(Netherlands).  Paper from the Project on Human Potential.
From the earliest historical period up to the present, Hindus have linked education
with religion.  This paper examines the evolution of the Hindu educational system
from the Vedic period (up to 1000 B.C.) to the present.  Topics covered include the
historical development of the Hindu education from the earliest period when it
consisted of recitation of the Vedas to the Brahmana period which led to the
development of the Laws of Manu, the rule of religious and social life for Hindus,
and later periods.  Other areas discussed are teaching methods and objectives in
traditional primary schools, the central position of the student-teacher relationship,
higher education from the Vedic period to 1200 A.D., and teaching methods used in
an educational system emphasizing memorization.  Separate sections also deal with:
(1) the evolution of women's education from the earlier period, when women were
freer to participate, to the period beginning around 500 B.C.  when women's
educational opportunities declined; and (2) the philosophy of education, which
emphasized the importance of education for illumination, greater piety, and character
development.  A seven-page list of project research papers concludes the document.
Tait, Alice A.; Perry, Robert B. (1987). The Sociological Implications of the Civil
Rights Movement for Black Character Development and Generic Programming within
the Television Medium, 1955-1985. Negro Educational Review; v38 n4 p224-37.
Examines the portrayal of the Black experience on television in relation to civil rights
legislation during the period.  Reviews various television programs and finds that
despite an increase in the number of Black characters on the air, stereotyping has
remained a problem.  
United States Department of State. (1989). Cultural Orientation. Young Adult
Curriculum: Introduction. Washington, DC: Center for Applied Linguistics, Refugee
Service Center, Author.
The cultural orientation curriculum for young adults in the International Catholic
Migration Commission's Philippine Refugee Processing Center is discussed and
outlined.  The program's goals for emotional and character development
(self-awareness and self-esteem, cultural awareness, pro-activity, personal
responsibility), knowledge of cultural information and resettlement realities, and
cross-cultural adaptation skills (problem-solving, goal-setting and planning,
information seeking, stress management, and socialization) are specified.  The
curriculum's organization is described, including the four major unit topics (self,
family and home, work/school/peers, and community and society); use of themes and
projects; and the emphasis on learning skills related to American socialization, such as
throwing a frisbee.  Commonly-used classroom instructional techniques are also
described briefly.  Additional materials include an outline of themes for each unit, a
series of forms for developing individual student profiles, a reprinted article on the
program's young adult emphasis, and descriptions of the young adult services and
classroom crisis components of the program.  
Wharton-Boyd, Linda P. (1983). The Significance of Black American Children's
Singing Games in an Educational Setting. Journal of Negro Education; v52 n1 p46-56.
Discusses how Black children's singing games may be applied to enhance education in
the areas of (1) curriculum content and philosophy; (2) teaching strategies; (3) child
assessment; (4) character development; and (5) development of self-expression.
Bibliographies
Cochrane, Don. (1988). Bibliography on Moral Development, Values Education, and
Character Development. Moral Education Forum; v13 n1 p14-30.
Provides a bibliography on moral development, values education, and character
development.  The bibliography is divided into two parts: (1) cites 17 books published
between 1985 and 1988, and (2) covers 282 journal articles and ERIC documents
published between 1986 and 1988.
Selected References. (1988). A Special Report: Developing Character. Principal; v68
n2 p28-29.
Provides a bibliography of 41 books and reports on character development themes
such as values education, civic responsibility, family and societal influences, ethical
instruction, traditional American and religious values, and parental involvement.